Israel Nature and Parks Authority

The Conservation of the Archeological Parks

The use of St. Astier Natural Hydraulic Limes
 
Logo
Restoring Stonework Restoring Pillar Restoring In progress
Restoration of Stonework Eroded Stonework Preparation
 First Preliminary Report 
Prepared by Asi Shalom September 2000

Preface

The National Archaeological Parks of Israel include great and important epics of history from the beginning of humanity through biblical and classical times.

During the past century and in recent times, these sites were and still are archaeologically excavated. Although new finds shed new light on the mysteries of the past, it is evident that the greatest challenge is to conserve what has been exposed.

The fate of historical and architectural structures which have suffered destruction and abandonment but which still portray and hint at the culture and ideology of life of the humans who have built the sites, is at risk.
To conserve all these sites in the most authentic manner using comparable materials and minimal intervention and to maintain them for this and for future generations. This is the goal - this is the challenge!


Comparable and compatible materials

After many years of the damaging use of incompatible, cementitious materials, the last decade has seen the revival of mortars, plasters and renders made of lime or earth in the conservation of archaeological sites. The use of cementitious mixes is not, however, the only potentially damaging intervention. As incorrect is the use of non cementitious materials that are assumed to be suitable by conservators or specifiers who, without any research into the products, are relying on uninformed opinions or practice.

An aspect to be always considered is the state of these structures today. To examine the old mortars and prepare a comparable one is the practice. The problem is, however, that many historical buildings, sites and, evidently, ruins now bear little resemblance, in their exposed and deteriorated state, to their original and complete form. These structures and the relevant building materials are often weakened and damaged. The temptation, which in many cases is still the practice, to utilise very strong, non porous, inflexible or adulterated materials and low cost, unskilled, labour is indeed great. The irreversible damages to monuments and sites caused by such ill-informed interventions can be seen everywhere as a testimony of their destructiveness, which is mostly irreversible and absolute.

The use of inappropriate materials and unskilled hands can now no longer be justified in any way, since suitable pure and natural materials and the skills to use them are readily available. The way that these materials should be used is in the hands of conservators and specifiers. The principle should be to work with materials that, if possible are comparable but which in all cases must be compatible taking into consideration the state and exposure of the structures, the extent of conservation or restoration needed and desired durability.
 

 



Patching Erosion

2000 year-old lime plaster, miraculously surviving and urgently awaiting conservation treatment.





Mosaic floor during careful conservation treatment.
.

Stone Facade

Soft-stone facade deteriorated to point of collapse.




The use of St. Astier Natural Hydraulic Limes (NHL).


There is an urgent need to confront the forces of decay represented by changes and extremes in climates, exposure, neglect and damage caused by previous uninformed interventions with inappropriate materials ( including the use of weak materials in unstable surroundings or gauged with cement), large number of visitors, vandalism and so on. The use of St. Astier limes has given us the chance to work with these scarred structures providing compatible mortars that will preserve their historical testimony for future generations.

Having these limes as versatile binders for large and varying uses has given us the needed flexibility, a relatively simple and speedy application and long term durability: all these are vital elements in building national conservation and maintenance plans for almost 50 National Archeological Parks.

In almost 3 years of use, we have tested, applied and are able to make on-going assessment of the qualities and performance of these limes in mortars, plasters, renders, surface consolidation, flooring, sacrificial coatings, grouting, injection, casting and as an additive to earth mortars, in the conservation and restoration of structures ranging from fragile to solid, deteriorating to stable, minute to massive. These sites are of the outmost importance to be preserved for the future. Many of them are not only significant for Israel but belong to the historical, social and religious development of our modern society.
 
 
Bedding for Lime Floor
    Bedding for a lime floor surounding a   
    mosaic

 
Wall Plaster
Conservation of fragile lime wall plasters
Bath House Reconstruction of a vault  
of a Bath-House on the  
edge of a 400 metre abyss

The varying uses of St. Astier NHLs
 Mosaic Floors 
  • Injecting and filling of voids in bedding - NHL-2
  • Replacement of tesserae - NHL-3.5
  • Filling lacunae - NHL-3.5
  • Filling joints between tesserae - NHL-2
  • Closing of borders - NHL-3.5
Tesserae
Replacement of tesserae 
Mosaic Restoration   Stabilised mosaic in   passage-way allowing   visitors to walk on

Voids
Injecting and filling of voids under the mosaic
Lime floors:
  • Stabilization of original - NHL-2
  • Integration to original - NHL-2
  • Reconstruction of bedding - NHL-5
  • Repaving of floors for walking - NHL-5
Bedding
Paving
Repaving of floors allowing passage of visitors directly on floors as in ancient times.
The original remains have been documented, stabilised and protected.

 Lime plaster:
 
 
                - Consolidation by injection - NHL-2/NHL-3.5     Filling Cracks
Filling of borders and cracks. 
 
                - Integration to original - NHL-2. 
                - Filling of borders, cracks - NHL-2. 
                - Re-plastering of walls - NHL-2. 
Plaster Panels
Supporting of lime plaster
panels during consolidation
 

The lime plaster conservation project at Qumeran National Park was a school for plaster conservation. Every kind of thinkable problem in plaster decay occurred on the site.

 

Pathway
Steps
Stairwal
Conservation of the plasters in the water system of Qumeran

One of the greatest challenges was an unusually large render panel in one of the grand pools which was detached more than 10 cm from bedding and wall and miraculously survived and waited for treatment.
The pictures below try to depict the challenge:

Pool
The large panel on the wall of the grand pool detached by uncontrolled flood waters from above.
Lime Fasteners
Example of lime fasteners
Large Void
The careful cleaning of the huge void after securing the panel with lime fasteners and gauze with weak solution of acrylic resin

Liquid Mortar
Filling of the voids from all directions with liquid mortar made of NHL - 2 and pieces of light-weight high fired ceramic balls and ancient pottery sherds
                
Filled Void
The finished result:
A surprising and amazing success!
Earth plaster: 
- 
Additive to high-clay earth plasters - NHL-2.
- 
Additive to earth sacrificial layers - NHL-2.

Mud Plastered Wall
A badly deteriorated mud-brick and mud plastered wall
Mud Brick Structure
Retouching mud bricks, NHL 2/mud
replastering and sacrificial protection layers

White Cement Damage
An earlier intervention with white cement causing evident damage on this ancient mud brick and lime
Repair in Progress
Consolidation of mud bricks and integration to original. The same wall after having removed the cement and replastered with NHL 2
Masonry walls: Fissures 

            - Bedding mortar - NHL-3.5.
            - Pointing mortar - NHL-2.
            - Wall-core mortar - NHL-3.5.
            - Capping of wall tops - NHL-5.
            - Filling of cracks - NHL-2.

Packing rock fissures with earth mortar


Wall Core Mortar
Filling "voids" in wall-core mortar.
Vault
Bedding mortar in vault reconstruction.

Soft stone repair:
              - Casting of "stone slabs" - NHL-5.
              - Bedding mortar for slabs - NHL-2/3.5.
              - Filling of cracks - NHL-2.
              - "Stone like" sacrificial layer - NHL-2/3.5.
              - Stone surface consolidation - NHL-2.
Consolidation of Soft Stone
Stone conservation: consolidation of
soft stone with NHL 2 lime water
Sacrificial Layer
     "Stone like" sacrificial layer.
         Pointing
Filling of limestone tiles bedded in an NHL 2 mortar in cavernously decayed soft limestone. The pointing uses NHL 2 mortar with limestone pins.
Casting of stone decorations:
                    - Round column pieces - NHL-5.
                    - Masoned column base - NHL-5 + gypsum.
 
 
Column

 Filling of voids in columns with cast stone slabs




                       Column Base
                           Detail of cast base before final coat.
Plastered Column
 Cast, plastered column and base
  Stucco Repair
Intergration of stucco repairs with original volutes on Ionic column
These are some of the sites where the St. Astier NHL's have been pre tested and are now being used and monitored on on-going conservation and restoration work with professional conservators.

Masada National Park:
The leading archaeological site in Israel with more than 800,000 visitors per year ;
a King's fortress including all classical Roman luxuries ; the heroic episode of the Jewish zealots and the Byzantine retreat - Masada has all of the conservation challenges and was the first site in Israel to use St. Astier NHLs on the recommendation of Prof. John Ashurst - the conservation architect of the Northern Palace Project and a consultant to the Authority.


National Park

  
  
  
Qumeran National Park:

A small site with international fame and mystery. Home of the Dead Sea Scrolls, an ingenious water system using run-off flood waters chanelled to fill a huge system of plastered cisterns. Excavated evidence points to a site of communal living although recent discoveries place it as a villa of a king's vassal from the 2nd Temple period.
An enormous challenge to conserve the plastered water system and exposed earth construction.



National park aerial view
  
  
  
Tel Sheva National Park:


A biblical site from the 1st Temple period boasting an underground water system similar to sites of Meggido and Hazor. An ongoing task to inject voids between the quarried walls and its thick lining plaster. The work is in a micro-climate, monitored and documented and has been going on for 3 years.






Tel Sheva
  
  

Mamshit National Park:


A Nabataean site situated on the northern part of the spice road from Yemen - Petra - Gaza. The site was of wealthy merchants villas, horse breeding and possibly, school for architects.
It boasts structures from the Roman and Byzantine periods and has an on-going maintenance plan which included the re-instating of major church mosaics and work on the Baptistery.




Aerial view  
  
  
  

Conclusion


We are currently extending the use of St. Astier NHLs to many other Archaeological National Parks to aid in conservation of similar situations and contend with new, interesting challenges.


Our 3 years of experiment and experience have given us great confidence in the performance of these materials. There is every indication that their permeability, flexibility and durability will provide us with the necessary compatible materials to continue to preserve our exposed historical ruins, monument and sites.


Restored Columns Columns and Stonework
    
Floor
As it may have once looked - according to archaeological evidence from excavations.


A final remark to be made is on the role of the Authorities. They must be the ultimate guide in the choice of correct materials, recognice the work of good conservators and restorers and provide adequate funding for testing and research to preserve cultural patrimonies that otherwise could be lost forever.
Logo

For further Guidance, contact your St Astier Distributor.